Westworld vs The Walking Dead: explorations of humanity

img_0002

What makes us human, compared to losing our humanity – The Walking Dead walks all over Westworld when it comes to the meaning of life.

What makes us human, compared to losing our humanity – The Walking Dead walks all over Westworld when it comes to the meaning of life.

The Westworld viewing experience is cold, sterile – about as exciting as a conversation with a robot actually would be. Despite the special effects, the high-flown cast, the sets, the gazillions of dollars blown on this turkey, it never really comes to life. It already seems stale, predictable.

Compare Westworld’s relentless big-budget HD shine to the gloomy prison scenes of Seasons 3 and 4 of The Walking Dead – mostly shot in the dark to make up for the lack of special effects. Even at the time while fans complained the, ‘scarier because you can’t quite see it,’ vibe was starting to pall, everyone kept watching. Dissatisfied, but still engaged.

Imagine if they turned the lights off over at Westworld. [In fact, they probably are, right about now].

Questioning what it is to be human is certainly not a new idea. Neither is questioning what makes humans different from monsters, machines, apes or even puppets. So what does Westworld add to what is essentially a 21st Century re-telling of Pinocchio combined with Frankenstein’s Monster?

So what does Westworld add to what is essentially a 21st Century re-telling of Pinocchio combined with Frankenstein’s Monster?

Compare again, The Walking Dead’s almost nuanced (given the context) exploration of the concept of humanity in the sixth season. The core characters have managed to keep two children alive and thoughts about their future has led the group to consider how far they will go to survive. To their credit, they have so far mostly managed to avoid murder, rape, theft, slavery and cannibalism in the fading hope of living a peaceful life.

By contrasting the core cast with new characters who have survived largely untouched, we see how far Rick et al have traveled from their pre-apocalypse selves. The ironic set, consisting of beautiful show homes in an unfinished  housing development now called Alexandria, highlights how brutalised our heroes have become. The Alexandrians sleep in beds with sheets, look good and are great at shaving, cutting hair and baking cookies, but woefully short of supplies and basic zombie-killing skills. They represent contemporary 21st century humanity.

This vision of what folks used to be like, and the cookies – mainly the cookies – leads core character Carol to have some kind of spiritual/existential crisis. She follows Morgan’s lead in refusing to kill any more people, even in self-defense. Even though they recognise that this disqualifies both of them from membership of an interdependent community they cannot defend during an attack. So their refusal to kill, both humanises and dehumanises them.

The Walking Dead essentially offers four expressions of humanity: passive (and doomed); brutalised; bestial; post-human, i.e. dead, but ambulatory. The walking dead used to be human, but they have lost their intellectual and emotional abilities through catastrophic brain damage. They are now parasitic predators feeding off their human hosts.

The Walking Dead offers four expressions of humanity: passive (and doomed); brutalised; bestial; post-human, i.e. dead, but ambulatory.

Conversely, the hosts and the majority of the core characters in Westworld are the non-humans. They too have limited emotional and cognitive powers but for at least part of the time, we are asked to share their worldview. In a novel, this could have been really interesting, on film, not so much. The robots repetitively speak to each other, re-running their scripted conversations as a form of self-correcting. We can watch the robots analyse their own behaviour but with the exception of sexbot brothel keeper, Maeve, we can’t see how their worldview expands as they make new connections between pieces of data and imperfectly erased ‘memories’. In episode 4, Maeve makes a cognitive leap and asks another robot to dig into her abdomen to retrieve a bullet that is lodged there. But we are unable to hear the robotic ‘interior monologue’ that brings her to that cognitive leap.

Sad little robot Dolores, the madonna figure in a symbolic blue dress, has been programmed to want to be free, but free to do what?  To eat, to drink, to reproduce herself via a 3D printer? Or simply to decommission herself – putting herself into storage or being broken up for spares. In this Jurassic Park with robots, we are told that there is only a single line of code stopping the robots from fighting back. If they were programmed to feed on humans, then in their current state, there would be little difference between the Westworld robots and the Walking Dead zombies.

In Westworld the tourists of the future flock to this extremely expensive theme park to live out their Wild West fantasies: duelling, whoring, saloon bar brawling, riding out with the Sheriff to capture bandits hidden in the admittedly spectacular hills. So far, so Disneyworld – since the tourists can’t hurt each other or be hurt themselves – which begs the question why robots were necessary in the first place. Human hosts could do the job just as well so long as everyone had blanks in their revolvers.

Because, Westworld suggests, we humans are so base that given the freedom to live out our wildest fantasies, we will immediately take the chance to ‘go black hat all the way’ and start a vacation-long rampage of lynching, raping and randomly killing, all core ingredients of the Western genre.

To pander to the tourists’ fantasies, the robots at Westworld are pretty machines designed to be hurt for fun. That is the real purpose and main selling point of the park.

To pander to the tourists’ fantasies, the robots at Westworld are pretty machines designed to be hurt for fun. That is the real purpose and main selling point of the park.

The world-weary designer of the park, Robert Ford, played by a suitably saturnine Anthony Hopkins who may or may not be a robot himself,  believes that humanity will evolve no further. There is no disease that can’t be cured, therefore homo sapiens sapiens has reached the end of its physical development.  We are led to infer that Ford will use his creations to develop an entirely new species by spreading concealed viruses that will develop imagination, or creativity. He also seems to be introducing a new religion, with himself as a god. Ford’s aim is sentience for his lifelike but not living creatures. Other members of the park maintenance crew would prefer the robots to be less ‘sentient’, less aware or conscious, given what they are programmed to suffer.

Meanwhile, the psychiatrist is playing mind games with Dolores, teaching her to read Lewis Carroll in between being raped and murdered and having her entire family wiped out. By other robots as well as tourists. And a seriously nasty ‘billionaire philanthropist’ in a black hat who really looks like a robot (Ed Harris), is causing complete chaos by trying to find a maze, supposedly located at the centre of the park, which will take the park’s ‘game’ to a whole new level.

But there’s no sense of danger, no real fight for survival in Westworld. Yes, the robots can be physically hurt where the humans cannot, and yes, they are programmed to suffer – but they can also be rebuilt, operated on, repaired and reprogrammed and their suffering switched off with a single voice command. They are frequently given new scripts and new roles to play. Some of them are condemned to a storyline/life of torture but they are not actually alive, everything they learn is erased each time their storyline ends. Even if they do achieve some kind of sentience, consciousness, what exactly is it that they want? To live, to be free, to die?

Right from the first few minutes of the first episode of The Walking Dead, there has been only one goal – to stay alive. A secondary goal is to retain as much humanity as possible while doing it. Westworld lacks any such narrative drive.

Right from the first few minutes of the first episode of The Walking Dead, there has been only one goal – to stay alive. A secondary goal is to retain as much humanity as possible while doing it. Westworld lacks any such narrative drive.

In Season 1 of The Walking Dead, when the original characters hesitated to kill the zombies because they used to be neighbours or even family members, we cheered each time Rick and his merry band of survivors beat up a ravenous attacker. In keeping with the Horror genre, we could almost smell the rotting guts and gore as they were thrown around, heads and limbs ripped off or crushed, knives stabbed into eye sockets of human-shaped monsters.The victims used to be human, but now they are not. So it’s ok to subject them to extreme levels of gratuitous violence only permissible on a cable channel.

In Season 7 of The Walking Dead the zombies are far less human in appearance than they were in Season 1. Theirs is indeed a self-limiting illness for they will, eventually, starve to death. So the less human the dead appear and the more desensitized we have become, the more the series has had to ramp up the violence in other ways. The dead have more or less become an annoying sideshow as the series is now cannibalising itself by turning on its core cast with graphic human-on-human violence. There were some genuinely sickening moments in Season 7 episode 1 and many fans feel that it has crossed a line.

The Walking Dead have more or less become an annoying sideshow as the series is now cannibalising itself by turning on its core cast with graphic human-on-human violence.

But that is the other facet of being human, the capacity for cruelty, for destruction. If there comes a time when human beings need a theme park that allows them to act out fantasies of rape, pillage and general mayhem, then really, where’s the harm? This is the question the creators haven’t asked themselves even as the ratings for television shows that revel in gratuitous violence continue to grow. The robots are a lot prettier than the walking dead, but they’re no more – probably even less – human.

How many viewers will stick around to watch the Westworld robots develop sentience, a purpose, and then follow them through the long journey to self-determination and the decision to avenge themselves on human beings? The Terminator covered that in about 30 seconds.

One thought on “Westworld vs The Walking Dead: explorations of humanity

  1. Great essay! I gave up on The Walking Dead after Neagan’s major character kill opener of last season, broke my heart and the show has just gotten too over the top it was making me sad! I am just now getting into Westworld (a couple episodes in) so I will have to revisit your essay again after I finish the first season of WW.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s